Short Runs . Limited Seating . Key West Talent
2025-2026 Season
Personal Effects
A new Key West play by Chris Moore. Siblings arrive on the island to sort through the personal effects of their estranged, now deceased, father. They must face their old wounds as they are forced to reconcile the image of a popular island icon with the father who abandoned them. A World Premiere. Starring Sarah Goodwin, Aramis Ikatu, Tim Dahms, and Mariah Woessner.
Tickets: $45-$65 (does not include fees)
December 9-13, 2025
—> 7:00pm
The Armory
—>600 White Street
Holiday Lights Train Ride
Get your HO HO HO on with the Fringe, Tuesday Dec 16th, and enjoy live holiday music and a festive tour of the island’s holiday lights! Check-in begins at 7pm at the beautiful Gardens Hotel (526 Angela Street) where award-winning vocalist Claire Caplan and pianist Larry Smith will be the perfect prelude to the evening’s ride. (You might find inspiration to ‘jingle your bells’ on the dance floor at the Garden’s cash bar!) Then at 8:30pm it’s All Aboard the Holiday Train! Support Fringe Theater’s education and outreach programs by celebrating the holidays with friends!
Tickets: $65 (does not include fees)
Tuesday, December 16, 2025
—> 7:00pm: Check-in, 8:30pm: Train Ride
The Gardens Hotel
—>526 Angela Street
70 Girls 70
A rogue group of senior citizens take on a life of crime to raise the funds they need to save their apartment building in NYC. This Kander & Ebb classic is “a joyously imperfect and irresistibly funny musical!” We’re producing the show in a concert format. What does that mean? We'll narrate the action and stage the songs! Cast: Karen Grant, Jim Speake, Camille Toler, Barbara Mundy, Andrew Theede, Vanessa McCaffrey, Jordan Sommer, Wilhelmina Lopez-Martin, Merle Dimbath, Dominic Paolillo, Kathy Russ, Jim Argoudelis & Glenda Donovan.
Tickets: $45-$65 (does not include fees)
January 21-31, 2026
—> 7:00pm (5pm on Jan. 25)
The Armory
—>600 White Street
Letters From Max
This poignant and deeply intimate play premiered off-broadway in 2023 at Signature Theater in NYC. Witty and deeply human. It explores the emerging friendship of a professor and her student Max. Their love of words bind them in a wide and voracious conversation that eventually tests poetry's capacity to put to words the ineffable. Based on a true story. An Outer Critics Circle Nominee. Featuring Wende Shoer and Thomas Masat.
Tickets: $45-$65 (does not include fees)
February 18-20, 2026
—> 7:00pm
The Armory
—>600 White Street
Crimes of the Heart
Beth Henley’s beloved Pulitzer Prize winning script. Three eccentric sisters. A forgotten birthday, a failed career, an attempted murder. Funny. Messy. Filled with southern comfort. Featuring Martha Hooten-Hattingh, Alexa DoLuca, Abigail Emerson, Samantha Laskey, Dan Dempsey, and Dominic Paolillo.
Tickets: $45-$65 (does not include fees)
March 11-21, 2026
—> 7:00pm (5pm on March 15)
The Armory
—>600 White Street
And Tell Sad Stories of the Death of Queens
Little-known short plays by Tennessee Williams that boldly explore sexuality, identity, and longing. Presented in partnership with the Tennessee Williams Festival at Williams Hall. Directed by Dominic Paolillo. Cast: Kitty Clements, Cassidy Timms, Aramis Ikatu, Phillip Cole, Todd Glenn, Jim Speake, Trey Forsyth, Diane May, Chris Massicotte, Kathy Russ, Mariah Woessner, Davis Stack, Barbara Mundy.
Tickets: $30 (does not include fees)
March 11-21, 2026
—> 7:00pm (5pm on March 15)
Venue: Williams Hall
—>729 Fleming Street
The Shark is Broken
Written by Ian Shaw and Joseph Nixon
The Hit of the Edinburgh Fringe 2019
Three actors. One small boat. Alcohol flows. Egos clash. A cinematic shoot that will make history -- assuming someone can figure out how to fix that blasted shark. This 'bitingly funny' play is the true story of behind the scenes of the movie JAWS. Starring: Trey Forsyth, Mathias Maloff, and Ray West.
Tickets: $45-$65 (does not include fees)
April 15-25, 2026
—> 7:00pm (5pm on March 15)
The Armory
—>600 White Street